Is Berber Carpet a Good Choice?
How to select the right carpet style and grade for your home and avoid common consumer carpet buying mistakes. Is Berber Carpet a Good Choice?
Berber Style Carpet with Large Loops
Is Berber Carpet with Loops a Good Choice?
Q. How well does Berber withstand high traffic areas? Is it easy to keep clean and what kind of padding is best? I am going crazy trying to decide if I want a plush or Berber. I have a newborn and know I will soon have lots of messes to clean up!
Alan’s Response:
My advice? Don’t spend a lot on new carpet if you have small children!
Children are very hard on carpets, they spill everything imaginable. Parents are often too busy or too tired to clean up messes quickly enough to keep up with the demand.
Looped Berbers made from the Olefin Fiber are hard to keep clean and they snag easily. Looped Berber styles are not recommended for families with active children or pets.
For folks without active children or pets: Berber may be a good choice.
Fact: Inexpensive looped Berber carpets tend to snag easily and mat down more quickly.
Berber Carpet Snags and Pulls are common.
Most Berber styles are made with loops. Some Berbers are called “cut and loop” having both loops and cut loops.
Some Berbers have patterns and some do not, and still other Berber styles have no loops at all.
Berber Carpet Fibers…
Berber style carpets are often made from Nylon or Olefin, and of the two, Nylon would be the better and more durable choice.
Nylon Berbers cost more but can last years longer, and nylon Berber styles clean much easier than Berbers made from Olefin.
Berber Carpet Complaints
Why do Olefin Berber carpets attract dirt and are so hard to keep clean?
All Berber styles are elegant and beautiful when new. However, there is a common complaint from homeowners with Berber carpets made from the Olefin fiber.
Consumers often report that within a week or two after a professional cleaning. Previous spots and stains tend to reappear as if they were never cleaned at all.
Is Berber a good choice? Berber Stains
This is because the Olefin fiber is inherently oily and often makes Olefin hard to clean and prone to attracting dirt like a magnet.
Old stains tend to reappear again and again regardless of how many times you have the spots cleaned.
Why do Olefin fibers attract dirt?
Here’s why… During the manufacturing process the Olefin fiber is naturally oily.
Fiber makers use a special process to clean the Olefin fibers to try to remove these oils, but often cut corners in order to reduce costs.
Some manufacturers put their Olefin fibers through a “three-phase” cleaning process to try to remove most of the oils.
To make a better product, the fiber maker will use a “five-phase” cleaning process which removes much more of these oils from the fiber.
This makes a significantly less-oily fiber that cleans much easier and doesn’t attract dirt nearly as much.
Using the five-phase process to removing excess oils from Olefin is a more time consuming and costly procedure, so manufacturers charge more for these premium fibers.
Unfortunately consumers have no way of knowing which Olefin fibers have been cleaned with the “five-phase” process and those that have only had the three-phase cleaning.
Rule of thumb: I think it would be reasonable to assume that most Berbers priced under $15.00 per yard would be made using the “three-phase” process.
You might have to spend $20 per yard or more to get the better grade of olefin fiber.
Most carpet salespeople have no knowledge about this manufacturing process and asking them questions about it might be futile.
Fact: It’s the fiber type and the size of the loops that matters most.
Inexpensive Olefin Berbers snag easily and are priced at less than $15 per yard. Don’t assume that this low-quality carpet will last more than a few years for you.
If you have active kids or pets, I think you should buy something more durable.
Large Loops vs Small Loops
Berber styles that have Large loops tend to collapse and fall over more quickly.
This makes the carpet appear worn out and ugly, often within a year or two. This is common in main traffic lanes, on stairs and down hallways.
Smaller looped Berbers tend to resist matting and crushing better and retain its like-new appearance longer.
Berbers made of Nylon are much more durable and will resist matting and crushing of the pile longer than any other synthetic fiber.
If a Berber carpet is priced under $15 per yard, then it is likely made of Olefin and designed to last a few years at best.
You’ll be plagued with lots of snags, pulls, runs and stains that are hard to remove. This is why Berber is a bad choice for folks with active kids or pets.
A good quality Nylon Berber would clean easier, wear better, and retain its new appearance much longer than would an Olefin Berber.
If made with smaller loops, would it be more durable?
Yes! If you decide buy a Berber carpet and want it to last, be sure to select one with smaller loops, as the bigger loops tend fall over quickly and look worn out sooner.
Berber Carpet Padding
As far as pad goes, an 8-pound minimum density, and a 1/4″ to 3/8″ thickness is required for virtually all Berber styles.
Another option you might want to consider would be selecting a Berber made without loops, these are called a “cut-Berber” or a “California Berber” style.
Here is a Cut Berber or California Berber Style.
Some Berbers are made from wool, which is a natural fiber and very durable, but are very costly, usually over $80 per square yard.
What grade of carpet should you choose for your home? Take my free Carpet Foot-Traffic Test to find out!
Notice how the border carpet (in brown) is smooth compared to the level-loop styles shown next to it. You can also choose a “Cut & Loop Style” to get the best features of both styles.
